Friday, January 1, 2010
How Team Mayweather May be Able to Weather the Defamation Storm
A Quick Review of the Necessary Elements of Defamation Per Se in the Backdrop of Manny Pacquiao’s Lawsuit Against Team Mayweather and How Team Mayweather May be Able to Succeed in Challenging the Lawsuit
Round one of the battle between boxing’s pound-for-pound best, Filipino sensation Manny (Pac Man) Pacquiao and the undefeated Floyd (Money) Mayweather took place about two and half months ahead of schedule. On December 30, 2009, at a time when boxing fans around the world remained cautiously optimistic that Mayweather and Pacquiao would put their respective feelings on the drug testing controversy aside and salvage the March 13, 2010 mega-bout, Pacquiao filed a federal complaint (the “Complaint”) in the United States District Court of the State of Nevada against Mayweather, as well as his father, Floyd Mayweather, Sr., his uncle and trainer, Roger Mayweather, Mayweather Promotions, LLC, Richard Schaefer, the Golden Boy Promotions executive who has been acting as Mayweather’s mouthpiece in negotiations for the Pacquiao fight, and Oscar De La Hoya (collectively the “Defendants”). The Complaint alleges a single cause of action, defamation per se, and cites to several specific instances where the Defendants purportedly made statements inferring that Pacquiao uses or has used performance-enhancing drugs. Since the filing of the Complaint, it has already been reported that the March 13, 2010 date is off, and with the legal wrangling that will inevitably occur in the coming weeks, some may wonder if this fight will ever happen at all. At the core of this lawsuit is not when or if the fight will happen, however, but rather a basic legal question: Can the Defendants be found liable for defamation per se pursuant to the allegations made in the Complaint? A brief analysis of this possibility follows.
What are the Elements of Defamation and Defamation Per Se?
There are two basic forms of defamation, libel, which is defamation in a written form, such as in a newspaper, magazine, or blog, and slander, which is a defamatory spoken statement. The basic elements of a defamation cause of action are: (1) a false statement; (2) publication of the false statement to a third party; (3) fault amounting to at least negligence on the part of the publisher if the defamatory matter is one of public concern; and (4) damage to the person alleging defamation. When alleging defamation per se, or defamation by, of, for, or in itself, proof of damage is not necessary. Rather, one must be able to establish simply that a defamatory statement was made. When a public figure brings an action for defamation, he or she must also show “actual malice,” or that the person making the statement at issue knew it to be false or issued the statement in reckless disregard to the truth. Mere opinions are legally protected.
What Can Team Mayweather Do First?
Upon service of a federal complaint, a defendant may either answer the complaint, meaning that he or she would provide an itemized written response to the allegations contained within the complaint, or make a motion to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b) and/or a motion for summary judgment pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56. Although Rule 12(b) provides seven separate grounds for filing a motion to dismiss, the most common ground is failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. By filing such a motion, a defendant is essentially alleging that the plaintiff has failed to allege the requisite elements of a given cause of action within the four corners of the complaint. To successfully oppose a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted, a plaintiff must show that he or she has, in fact, made a prima facie showing, or showing at first view, that he or she is entitled to the relief sought in the complaint as a matter of law.
Given the high stakes involved in Pacquiao v. Mayweather, one would anticipate that the Defendants, or at least a few of the Defendants, will be making a motion to dismiss the Complaint. In order to make a successful motion to dismiss, the Defendants will have to allege that Pacquiao failed to allege the requisite elements of a cause of action for defamation per se. Pacquiao would then have oppose the Defendants’ motion by showing that he made a prima facie showing to entitlement to relief for defamation per se as a matter of law. To do so, Pacquiao would have to walk each statement made concerning his use of performance-enhancing drugs that is referred to in the Complaint through the elements detailed above and show why, before the start of any depositions or other discovery, he has made a sufficient initial showing of defamation per se based on same. The federal court must then review the Complaint, review the arguments, review the case law supporting the arguments, and decide whether or not Pacquiao’s cause of action is legally sufficient as to all or some of the Defendants.
Can Team Mayweather Succeed in Having the Complaint Dismissed?
Pacquiao’s Complaint details seven or eight specific instances where he was purportedly defamed. Of the specific instances documented, three or four of them appear to indicate that Pacquiao uses or used performance-enhancing drugs, while the balance of the instances seem fall into the category of innuendo, inference, or opinion. The strongest claim appears to be against Roger Mayweather, who allegedly told the website Boxing Scene that “I know he’s got somethin’ in his system anyway.” This particular statement reportedly came on December 30, 2009, the same day the Complaint was filed and several days after Pacquiao first started telling the press that he would be filing a lawsuit. Unlike most of the others, Roger Mayweather’s quote most explicitly declares that Pacquiao uses performance-enhancing drugs as if it were a fact. An allegation against Richard Schaefer is concerning for similar reasons, but is not directly quoted. The Complaint is thus rather vague as to how defamatory Schaefer’s alleged statements actually were.
The weakest claim appears to be made against Oscar De La Hoya, whose written tirade on his blog about the drug-testing situation is quoted within the Complaint. De La Hoya’s blog reportedly read as follows:
“If Pacquiao, the toughest guy on the planet, is afraid of needles and having a few teaspoons of blood drawn from his system, then something is wrong. The guy has tattoos everywhere; he’s tattooed from top to bottom. You’re telling me he’s afraid of needles? Now I have to wonder about him. I’m saying to myself ‘Wow, those Mosley punches, those Vargas punches and those Pacquiao punches all felt the same.’ I’m not saying yes or no. I’m just saying that now people have to wonder, ‘Why doesn’t he want to do [even more blood tests]? Why is it such a big deal?[‘]”
The Complaint goes on to allege that De La Hoya also added that “[w]hy don’t you want to do it? C’mon. It’s only a little bit of blood. If you have nothing to hide, then do the test.”
Despite its incendiary nature, at no time within the language quoted above does De La Hoya expressly accuse Pacquiao of using performance-enhancing drugs. Instead, De La Hoya uses a fact about Pacquiao to undermine Pacquiao’s claims of a dislike of needles, opines about Pacquiao’s punching power as against prior, naturally bigger rivals, and opines that Pacquiao should submit to random testing if he has nothing to hide. The rest of the allegedly defamatory statements fall between Roger Mayweather’s and De La Hoya’s remarks in their degrees of severity. A few, like De La Hoya’s, arguably appear to be nothing more than opinion, which is legally protected. In sum, therefore, it would appear as if several of the Defendants might be able to stop Pacquiao in round one of the mega-fight of 2010 and be dismissed from the lawsuit if a motion to dismiss is made.
* * *
And Speaking of Casting Doubt on an Athlete’s Gifts, There’s Also the Danny Green vs. Roy Jones Controversy: Lost on the firestorm that is the Mayweather-Pacquiao drug testing controversy was the December 22, 2009 letter written by John S. Wirt, Chief Executive Officer of Square Ring Promotions, Roy Jones, Jr.’s promotional company, to the New South Wales Sports Authority, regarding the hand wraps used by IBO cruiserweight champion Danny (Green Machine) Green in his December 2, 2009 bout with Jones in Sydney, Australia . Wirt alleges in the letter that Green, who won the bout by first round technical knockout, used wraps that were both wider and of a different, less soft type than is allowed under New South Wales’ Boxing and Wrestling Control Regulations. Wirt thus requests that the result of the bout should be overturned.
While a quick look at the Regulations appears to support Wirt’s position, there are a few items to consider before joking that Danny Green is Australian for Antonio Margarito. First, Green’s wraps were allegedly inspected by New South Wales Sports Authority officials before the fight and were given clearance. It is thus an open question whether the New South Wales Sports Authority will rule against Green given its own potential culpability. Further, unlike Team Margarito’s placement of an overtly illegal substance on his hand wraps before his bout with “Sugar” Shane Mosley, Green’s allegedly improper wrapping appears to constitute, at best, a technical violation of the New South Wales Boxing and Wrestling Control Regulations. In other words, the wraps, as described in Wirt’s letter, may have been banned by the text of the Boxing and Wrestling Control Regulations, but may have not been otherwise improper if used in other jurisdictions. On the other hand, a Plaster of Paris-like substance, like the one found on Margarito’s wraps, is very likely banned by most every athletic commission worldwide.
Source: 8countnews.com
Round one of the battle between boxing’s pound-for-pound best, Filipino sensation Manny (Pac Man) Pacquiao and the undefeated Floyd (Money) Mayweather took place about two and half months ahead of schedule. On December 30, 2009, at a time when boxing fans around the world remained cautiously optimistic that Mayweather and Pacquiao would put their respective feelings on the drug testing controversy aside and salvage the March 13, 2010 mega-bout, Pacquiao filed a federal complaint (the “Complaint”) in the United States District Court of the State of Nevada against Mayweather, as well as his father, Floyd Mayweather, Sr., his uncle and trainer, Roger Mayweather, Mayweather Promotions, LLC, Richard Schaefer, the Golden Boy Promotions executive who has been acting as Mayweather’s mouthpiece in negotiations for the Pacquiao fight, and Oscar De La Hoya (collectively the “Defendants”). The Complaint alleges a single cause of action, defamation per se, and cites to several specific instances where the Defendants purportedly made statements inferring that Pacquiao uses or has used performance-enhancing drugs. Since the filing of the Complaint, it has already been reported that the March 13, 2010 date is off, and with the legal wrangling that will inevitably occur in the coming weeks, some may wonder if this fight will ever happen at all. At the core of this lawsuit is not when or if the fight will happen, however, but rather a basic legal question: Can the Defendants be found liable for defamation per se pursuant to the allegations made in the Complaint? A brief analysis of this possibility follows.
What are the Elements of Defamation and Defamation Per Se?
There are two basic forms of defamation, libel, which is defamation in a written form, such as in a newspaper, magazine, or blog, and slander, which is a defamatory spoken statement. The basic elements of a defamation cause of action are: (1) a false statement; (2) publication of the false statement to a third party; (3) fault amounting to at least negligence on the part of the publisher if the defamatory matter is one of public concern; and (4) damage to the person alleging defamation. When alleging defamation per se, or defamation by, of, for, or in itself, proof of damage is not necessary. Rather, one must be able to establish simply that a defamatory statement was made. When a public figure brings an action for defamation, he or she must also show “actual malice,” or that the person making the statement at issue knew it to be false or issued the statement in reckless disregard to the truth. Mere opinions are legally protected.
What Can Team Mayweather Do First?
Upon service of a federal complaint, a defendant may either answer the complaint, meaning that he or she would provide an itemized written response to the allegations contained within the complaint, or make a motion to dismiss pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b) and/or a motion for summary judgment pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56. Although Rule 12(b) provides seven separate grounds for filing a motion to dismiss, the most common ground is failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. By filing such a motion, a defendant is essentially alleging that the plaintiff has failed to allege the requisite elements of a given cause of action within the four corners of the complaint. To successfully oppose a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted, a plaintiff must show that he or she has, in fact, made a prima facie showing, or showing at first view, that he or she is entitled to the relief sought in the complaint as a matter of law.
Given the high stakes involved in Pacquiao v. Mayweather, one would anticipate that the Defendants, or at least a few of the Defendants, will be making a motion to dismiss the Complaint. In order to make a successful motion to dismiss, the Defendants will have to allege that Pacquiao failed to allege the requisite elements of a cause of action for defamation per se. Pacquiao would then have oppose the Defendants’ motion by showing that he made a prima facie showing to entitlement to relief for defamation per se as a matter of law. To do so, Pacquiao would have to walk each statement made concerning his use of performance-enhancing drugs that is referred to in the Complaint through the elements detailed above and show why, before the start of any depositions or other discovery, he has made a sufficient initial showing of defamation per se based on same. The federal court must then review the Complaint, review the arguments, review the case law supporting the arguments, and decide whether or not Pacquiao’s cause of action is legally sufficient as to all or some of the Defendants.
Can Team Mayweather Succeed in Having the Complaint Dismissed?
Pacquiao’s Complaint details seven or eight specific instances where he was purportedly defamed. Of the specific instances documented, three or four of them appear to indicate that Pacquiao uses or used performance-enhancing drugs, while the balance of the instances seem fall into the category of innuendo, inference, or opinion. The strongest claim appears to be against Roger Mayweather, who allegedly told the website Boxing Scene that “I know he’s got somethin’ in his system anyway.” This particular statement reportedly came on December 30, 2009, the same day the Complaint was filed and several days after Pacquiao first started telling the press that he would be filing a lawsuit. Unlike most of the others, Roger Mayweather’s quote most explicitly declares that Pacquiao uses performance-enhancing drugs as if it were a fact. An allegation against Richard Schaefer is concerning for similar reasons, but is not directly quoted. The Complaint is thus rather vague as to how defamatory Schaefer’s alleged statements actually were.
The weakest claim appears to be made against Oscar De La Hoya, whose written tirade on his blog about the drug-testing situation is quoted within the Complaint. De La Hoya’s blog reportedly read as follows:
“If Pacquiao, the toughest guy on the planet, is afraid of needles and having a few teaspoons of blood drawn from his system, then something is wrong. The guy has tattoos everywhere; he’s tattooed from top to bottom. You’re telling me he’s afraid of needles? Now I have to wonder about him. I’m saying to myself ‘Wow, those Mosley punches, those Vargas punches and those Pacquiao punches all felt the same.’ I’m not saying yes or no. I’m just saying that now people have to wonder, ‘Why doesn’t he want to do [even more blood tests]? Why is it such a big deal?[‘]”
The Complaint goes on to allege that De La Hoya also added that “[w]hy don’t you want to do it? C’mon. It’s only a little bit of blood. If you have nothing to hide, then do the test.”
Despite its incendiary nature, at no time within the language quoted above does De La Hoya expressly accuse Pacquiao of using performance-enhancing drugs. Instead, De La Hoya uses a fact about Pacquiao to undermine Pacquiao’s claims of a dislike of needles, opines about Pacquiao’s punching power as against prior, naturally bigger rivals, and opines that Pacquiao should submit to random testing if he has nothing to hide. The rest of the allegedly defamatory statements fall between Roger Mayweather’s and De La Hoya’s remarks in their degrees of severity. A few, like De La Hoya’s, arguably appear to be nothing more than opinion, which is legally protected. In sum, therefore, it would appear as if several of the Defendants might be able to stop Pacquiao in round one of the mega-fight of 2010 and be dismissed from the lawsuit if a motion to dismiss is made.
* * *
And Speaking of Casting Doubt on an Athlete’s Gifts, There’s Also the Danny Green vs. Roy Jones Controversy: Lost on the firestorm that is the Mayweather-Pacquiao drug testing controversy was the December 22, 2009 letter written by John S. Wirt, Chief Executive Officer of Square Ring Promotions, Roy Jones, Jr.’s promotional company, to the New South Wales Sports Authority, regarding the hand wraps used by IBO cruiserweight champion Danny (Green Machine) Green in his December 2, 2009 bout with Jones in Sydney, Australia . Wirt alleges in the letter that Green, who won the bout by first round technical knockout, used wraps that were both wider and of a different, less soft type than is allowed under New South Wales’ Boxing and Wrestling Control Regulations. Wirt thus requests that the result of the bout should be overturned.
While a quick look at the Regulations appears to support Wirt’s position, there are a few items to consider before joking that Danny Green is Australian for Antonio Margarito. First, Green’s wraps were allegedly inspected by New South Wales Sports Authority officials before the fight and were given clearance. It is thus an open question whether the New South Wales Sports Authority will rule against Green given its own potential culpability. Further, unlike Team Margarito’s placement of an overtly illegal substance on his hand wraps before his bout with “Sugar” Shane Mosley, Green’s allegedly improper wrapping appears to constitute, at best, a technical violation of the New South Wales Boxing and Wrestling Control Regulations. In other words, the wraps, as described in Wirt’s letter, may have been banned by the text of the Boxing and Wrestling Control Regulations, but may have not been otherwise improper if used in other jurisdictions. On the other hand, a Plaster of Paris-like substance, like the one found on Margarito’s wraps, is very likely banned by most every athletic commission worldwide.
Source: 8countnews.com
Manny Pacquiao will get Knocked Out in court
Can’t you just see the headlines when Manny loses his ridiculous lawsuit?
How ironic that the cocky/loud mouth Floyd Mayweather has stayed quiet during all of this and watched Team Pacquiao unravel themselves. Pacquiao is going to have a hard time troubling Mayweather with this “slander” lawsuit (which everyone knows is just a ploy to draw attention away from his own suspicious behavior) when Mayweather Jr. hasnt made any comments regarding his alleged steroid abuse.
This is a really stupid move by Pacquiao unless they are just using this as a negotiating ploy to make Mayweather drop his demands for blood testing throughout the training period. This lawsuit opens Manny Pacquiao up to so much investigation about his training techniques and others who believe and have stated that he uses PEDs.
If I were the lawyer representing Mayweather I would file a quick answer denying that Pacquiao has suffered any damages as a result of any statements made and asserting that as an affirmative defense that any statements that may have been made are in fact true.
I would then immediately schedule depositions with Manny Pacquiao himself, Freddie Roach, all of his former training partners, and anybody else who has been in any way involved in his training over the last ten years. I would also schedule a deposition of Arum and ask him about any and all conversations that he had with Pacquiao and any of his representatives about why they will not agree to the testing (this should delve a little farther than the public relations spin that they have tried to put on this).
I would then make the focus of our case that if Pacquiao is truly clean why won’t he agree to testing (this will resonate with a jury who doesn’t follow boxing). I would also immediately petition the Court to require Pacquiao to submit to random blood testing throughout the pending lawsuit. Pacquiao will surely fight that and the Judge would be unlikely to grant it, but again the fact that they fought the testing would resonate with the jury.
Pacquiao has got to understand that he has to prove that he has never used drugs. Mayweather does not have to prove that he is dirty! Pacquiao has to prove that he is clean. And given that he is unwilling to submit to tests a jury is going to have a hard time believing that. Additionally, because Pacquiao is a public figure he can’t just prove that it was unreasonable to think that he was on drugs, he has to prove that they knew that he was clean.
This is a tremendous burden. It is not as if he just has to prove he didn’t use drugs on a particular day or at a particular time. He has to prove that he never used PEDs and he has to prove that they knew he didn’t use them. And even if he is able to prove that, in order to obtain damages he has to prove that the allegations actually cost him money.
Forgive me if I have missed something, but I am not aware of any opportunity that has been denied Pacquiao because of anything that Mayweather or his camp said. Additionally, even he could prove that he lost money because of PED allegations how can he prove that the money that he lost was because of something Mayweather said or because of something Malignaggi or someone else said.
Speaking of Paulie Malignaggi, I wonder why he isn’t named in this lawsuit? It’s quite shocking that his name isn’t apart of the lawsuit as he has been the most vocal advocate for the Manny Pacquiao steroid rumors.
Malignaggi thinks the boxing media has dropped the ball, and not exercised due diligence in examining the possibility that Manny has used PEDs. In a recent interview he was quoted as saying….
“I understand most people like Manny, and not Floyd. Just cause that’s the case doesn’t mean Manny might not be cheating. It’s nothing to do with him personally. But I call a spade a spade. Too many people avoid the possibilities because Manny’s a likable person. He’s got that front, his country loves him. That front works like crazy. Floyd plays the bad guy, but he’s natural. Just don’t downplay the fact that Manny might be cheating. You have to open your eyes and at least be willing to look at it. This is bigger than me. The fact that the fight is not being made, you have to question the integrity of Pacquiao.”
Malignaggi was then asked why he has been so vocal about this issue and said “I don’t like cheaters,” “This is not baseball. You’re not just hitting home runs. You have to worry about peoples’ lives. Miguel Cotto in my opinion has been beaten by two cheaters. Manny if he’s cheating is taking away from guys who are doing things the right way. His team is reneging on their words.”
Source: officialscorecard.com
How ironic that the cocky/loud mouth Floyd Mayweather has stayed quiet during all of this and watched Team Pacquiao unravel themselves. Pacquiao is going to have a hard time troubling Mayweather with this “slander” lawsuit (which everyone knows is just a ploy to draw attention away from his own suspicious behavior) when Mayweather Jr. hasnt made any comments regarding his alleged steroid abuse.
This is a really stupid move by Pacquiao unless they are just using this as a negotiating ploy to make Mayweather drop his demands for blood testing throughout the training period. This lawsuit opens Manny Pacquiao up to so much investigation about his training techniques and others who believe and have stated that he uses PEDs.
If I were the lawyer representing Mayweather I would file a quick answer denying that Pacquiao has suffered any damages as a result of any statements made and asserting that as an affirmative defense that any statements that may have been made are in fact true.
I would then immediately schedule depositions with Manny Pacquiao himself, Freddie Roach, all of his former training partners, and anybody else who has been in any way involved in his training over the last ten years. I would also schedule a deposition of Arum and ask him about any and all conversations that he had with Pacquiao and any of his representatives about why they will not agree to the testing (this should delve a little farther than the public relations spin that they have tried to put on this).
I would then make the focus of our case that if Pacquiao is truly clean why won’t he agree to testing (this will resonate with a jury who doesn’t follow boxing). I would also immediately petition the Court to require Pacquiao to submit to random blood testing throughout the pending lawsuit. Pacquiao will surely fight that and the Judge would be unlikely to grant it, but again the fact that they fought the testing would resonate with the jury.
Pacquiao has got to understand that he has to prove that he has never used drugs. Mayweather does not have to prove that he is dirty! Pacquiao has to prove that he is clean. And given that he is unwilling to submit to tests a jury is going to have a hard time believing that. Additionally, because Pacquiao is a public figure he can’t just prove that it was unreasonable to think that he was on drugs, he has to prove that they knew that he was clean.
This is a tremendous burden. It is not as if he just has to prove he didn’t use drugs on a particular day or at a particular time. He has to prove that he never used PEDs and he has to prove that they knew he didn’t use them. And even if he is able to prove that, in order to obtain damages he has to prove that the allegations actually cost him money.
Forgive me if I have missed something, but I am not aware of any opportunity that has been denied Pacquiao because of anything that Mayweather or his camp said. Additionally, even he could prove that he lost money because of PED allegations how can he prove that the money that he lost was because of something Mayweather said or because of something Malignaggi or someone else said.
Speaking of Paulie Malignaggi, I wonder why he isn’t named in this lawsuit? It’s quite shocking that his name isn’t apart of the lawsuit as he has been the most vocal advocate for the Manny Pacquiao steroid rumors.
Malignaggi thinks the boxing media has dropped the ball, and not exercised due diligence in examining the possibility that Manny has used PEDs. In a recent interview he was quoted as saying….
“I understand most people like Manny, and not Floyd. Just cause that’s the case doesn’t mean Manny might not be cheating. It’s nothing to do with him personally. But I call a spade a spade. Too many people avoid the possibilities because Manny’s a likable person. He’s got that front, his country loves him. That front works like crazy. Floyd plays the bad guy, but he’s natural. Just don’t downplay the fact that Manny might be cheating. You have to open your eyes and at least be willing to look at it. This is bigger than me. The fact that the fight is not being made, you have to question the integrity of Pacquiao.”
Malignaggi was then asked why he has been so vocal about this issue and said “I don’t like cheaters,” “This is not baseball. You’re not just hitting home runs. You have to worry about peoples’ lives. Miguel Cotto in my opinion has been beaten by two cheaters. Manny if he’s cheating is taking away from guys who are doing things the right way. His team is reneging on their words.”
Source: officialscorecard.com
Why this crazy Pacquiao-Mayweather legal battle could turn ugly

When the anger that had been burning in Manny Pacquiao's perfectly flat and apparently legal belly for three months finally erupted in litigation, Floyd Mayweather Jr was rudely made aware that he has started a fight his lawyers will have to finish.
The little Filipino says he does not want to share a ring with a man he says thinks he is a drugs cheat – so he is suing him. There can't be a problem with that. It is up to Mayweather to back down – or defend himself, a skill he has perfected in the ring to the point of artistry.
It is hardly the sporting contest millions of boxing fans have been waiting for but, in the absence of sanity, it might have to do for the moment. And Pacquiao's lawyer, Daniel Petrocelli, says others might be named alongside Mayweather and members of his family and promotional team. This could get ugly. And drawn out.
How did a promotion that seemed to be going so smoothly come to this? If things looks too good to be true in boxing, they usually are. This is a story that suggests something else was always going on in the background.
First, the fighters' respective promoters, after quickly working out a mutually acceptable deal in nearly every respect, indulged themselves in a dangerous and tedious game of brinkmanship for nearly two weeks – at the end of which they have been reminded in the quick issue of a writ in the Nevada Federal Court yesterday that Pacquiao is not just a great fighter but a proud man.
They didn't know that already? He has legal history with Golden Boy Promotions going back to 2006, when he switched to Bob Arum's Top Rank. He was the feistiest deal-maker before agreeing to fight Ricky Hatton in May. Hatton's American promotional partners? Golden Boy. Pacquiao is nobody's doormat.
That he is prepared to defend his reputation so fiercely is not only predictable but the single nugget of integrity in a dispute that again makes professional boxing an international joke.
We have to wait now until supposedly wise men are jerked into compromise by the only language they speak: money. Otherwise, no fight – and that is inconceivable.
Still, there are too many odd twists in this tale. It is a case littered with idiocy and inconsistent moralising.
Since the row began, the Mayweathers have had the unquestioning support of Golden Boy's chief negotiator, Richard Schaefer, in their demand that Pacquiao submit to Olympic-standard random blood tests. Yet Schaefer steadfastly objected to blood tests for the shamed Shane Mosley only two years ago. Overnight, almost, Schaefer has become an avenging angel for the anti-drugs lobby.
Bob Arum, meanwhile, has been even more pro-active in the dispute on behalf of Pacquiao and has generated valuable ink for a fight that has captured an audience beyond boxing's hardcore, albeit for spurious reasons. He has talked tough, then backed down. Schaefer, to a lesser extent, has postured to no convincing effect. But the headlines have grown.
This is, after all, a bout – for Pacquiao's WBO welterweight title but really for the mythical pound-for-pound championship of boxing – that three million TV viewers in America will pay for, and probably half that again in the UK, plus whatever other markets the promoters can ginger up around the world.
Then into this mix is dropped the contentious suggestion that Pacquiao won't take random blood tests because he fears exposure as a drugs cheat. He denies the claim vehemently – and sues.
The numbers on offer for all concerned in the mega-fight of all time are considerable – yet we have been asked to believe that the fighters and their connections are willing to junk the promotion because of an unproven and, until three months ago, unvoiced suspicion about the most marketable boxer in the business.
So, how did they get themselves into such a fix? Here's a scenario that would not have displeased anyone on either side:
Mayweather did not get much of a workout in his comeback with Juan Manuel Marquéz in September, his first fight since stopping Hatton 21 months earlier. So, the theory goes, he was never going to fight Pacquiao on 13 March without a tune-up. He realises he risks his unbeaten record, perhaps even a knockout defeat, if he is not in peak form, so he looks for a way out, a postponement.
Pacquiao's trainer, Freddie Roach, was never that keen to take on Mayweather in March either, preferring to wait until the summer. He even mentions that Yuri Foreman, the new world light-middlweight champion who can't punch (and is promoted by Arum) might be an easy interim opponent, giving Pacquiao a chance to win his eighth world title at different weights – and upping his cachet in renewed negotiations with Mayweather.
Then Mayweather, for whatever reason, gives everyone "wriggle room" by calling for tests he knows Pacquiao will not agree to. The negotiations, which have been going suspiciously well, unravel and disintegrate.
Fight off. For now.
Pacquiao fights the smaller, less threatening Paulie Malignaggi or Foreman on 13 March... and Mayweather fights Matthew Hatton in the UK. These are mere ticking-over fights that nonetheless will milk the beast of a few more bucks.
The main event is postponed until Saturday, 1 May, nine days before Pacquiao runs for Congress in the Philippines. The fight grosses even more than the $200m (£123m) originally predicted.
Pacquiao beats Mayweather (as Mayweather, deep down, had feared he might). Pacquiao is elected to Congress.
Arum and Schaefer sit down to discuss the rematch, at the MGM Grand or the 100,000-plus-seater Cowboys Stadium in Texas later in the summer. Estimated revenue? $250m.
Stranger things have happened. And Bob Arum, 78 and still kicking, has been involved in quite a few of them.
Source: guardian.co.uk
Super-fight? Super farce
There are reasons why boxing is the only sport that consistently translates into great art, and they are the same reasons it is viewed with suspicion by many modern sports fans.
The boxing world is dark, dangerous and amoral, the sporting equivalent of the Wild West: no-one seems to know who's in charge, and many seem not to care. This apparently lawless environment froths with characters living by their own laws, while those in the civilised and sanitised world avert their gaze, genuinely amazed that such chicanery still goes on.
Some will doubtless accuse me of overstating my case in a fit of journalistic hysteria, but they will be those who haven't been following the unravelling story of Floyd Mayweather v Manny Pacquiao, the Fight of the Century that might never happen.
When negotiations for the fight came grinding to a halt two days before Christmas, I laid much of the blame at the door of Mayweather, who was insisting Philippines legend Pacquiao be subjected to random drug testing in the lead-up to the fight, which had been slated for 13 March, probably in Las Vegas.
My belief was that Mayweather was grandstanding, attempting to score psychological points, and that Pacquiao would soon put his pride aside and agree to play ball. In short, I thought Mayweather and his camp were just playing silly beggars.
Now, however, it is Pacquiao's reputation that is in the spotlight, whether he's guilty of any wrongdoing or not. Why, fans are asking, doesn't he just take the tests?
"I will provide any specimen, whether it be blood or urine samples, just right after the fight, but not a day or two before, for obvious reasons," fired back a furious Pacquiao. Problem is, Manny, the reasons aren't obvious at all.
Travis Tygart, the chief of the United States Anti-Doping Agency, who Mayweather's camp wants to oversee the testing, told the New York Times that not being blood tested in the 30 days prior to the fight, as Pacquiao is insisting on, "is totally unacceptable".
Tygart claimed "it would provide a huge loophole for a cheater to step through," before pointing out that basketball star Kobe Bryant and swimming great Michael Phelps have both undergone random testing of this type. If it's good enough for Bryant and Phelps, why not Pacquiao?
Meanwhile, the sheriffs in Mayweather's camp have been tying themselves up in knots with contradictory statements.
Head of Golden Boy promotions Richard Schaefer, whose outfit is representing Mayweather, has been nagging in his insistence that Pacquiao agree to random testing, yet it has emerged that Schaefer turned down Zab Judah's request for additional testing before his scheduled fight with Shane Mosley in 2008.
In an interview with the Associated Press, Schaefer said Mosley would not agree to "other tests than the Nevada [Athletic] Commission requires. The fact is Shane is not a cheater and he does not need to be treated like one". So, pretty much what Pacquiao is saying now then.
Mosley, it should also be noted, has admitted to unwittingly using illegal substances in the past.
There's the intrigue, now for the comedy. If the fight does fall through, Pacquiao's promoter Bob Arum has suggested his man will fight New Yorker Paulie Malignaggi instead.
This is the same Paulie Malignaggi who was torn to shreds by Ricky Hatton in Las Vegas last year, and the same Paulie Malignaggi who, following Pacquiao's savage destruction of Miguel Cotto last month, hinted in a raft of interviews that Pacquiao's rise through the weight divisions has been fuelled by performance-enhancing drugs.
Meanwhile, Hatton's younger brother Matthew, who has never even fought for a British title, has confirmed his representatives are in talks to fight Mayweather in the UK if the Pacquiao bout falls through.
"At first I thought it was a wind-up when my name was mentioned for Mayweather," said Hatton, echoing the thoughts of just about everyone else. A rematch with his older brother would have been a tough enough sell.
Matthew Hatton is a very respectable domestic fighter, but as far as Mayweather is concerned, it's the equivalent passing on a Beverly Hills date with Angelina Jolie and plumping for pie and mash with some actress off Eastenders instead.
Enough of the intrigue and the comedy, now for the tragedy. While the big shots are trashing the place, digging their spurs in and waving their pieces around with scant regard for the consequences, it's the poor saps who love boxing who are suffering.
There have been signs in recent years that those who run the sport are getting their act together, have finally realised that only by regularly matching the best against the best will boxing regain a foothold in the public consciousness.
To his credit, Pacquiao, who has ducked no-one, has been at the forefront of this revival, so too Mayweather, although to a lesser extent.
But if they are unable to put aside their differences and make this fight happen, there's a danger they'll be remembered by many for the wrong reason - not as the men who saved boxing, but as the men who turned their backs when boxing needed them most.
As I write, news reaches me that Pacquiao has filed a lawsuit alleging that Mayweather and others have falsely accused him of using performance-enhancing drugs. From super-fight to super farce, whatever happens between Mayweather and Pacquiao in court, millions will find boxing guilty.
Source: bbc.co.uk
The boxing world is dark, dangerous and amoral, the sporting equivalent of the Wild West: no-one seems to know who's in charge, and many seem not to care. This apparently lawless environment froths with characters living by their own laws, while those in the civilised and sanitised world avert their gaze, genuinely amazed that such chicanery still goes on.
Some will doubtless accuse me of overstating my case in a fit of journalistic hysteria, but they will be those who haven't been following the unravelling story of Floyd Mayweather v Manny Pacquiao, the Fight of the Century that might never happen.
When negotiations for the fight came grinding to a halt two days before Christmas, I laid much of the blame at the door of Mayweather, who was insisting Philippines legend Pacquiao be subjected to random drug testing in the lead-up to the fight, which had been slated for 13 March, probably in Las Vegas.
My belief was that Mayweather was grandstanding, attempting to score psychological points, and that Pacquiao would soon put his pride aside and agree to play ball. In short, I thought Mayweather and his camp were just playing silly beggars.
Now, however, it is Pacquiao's reputation that is in the spotlight, whether he's guilty of any wrongdoing or not. Why, fans are asking, doesn't he just take the tests?
"I will provide any specimen, whether it be blood or urine samples, just right after the fight, but not a day or two before, for obvious reasons," fired back a furious Pacquiao. Problem is, Manny, the reasons aren't obvious at all.
Travis Tygart, the chief of the United States Anti-Doping Agency, who Mayweather's camp wants to oversee the testing, told the New York Times that not being blood tested in the 30 days prior to the fight, as Pacquiao is insisting on, "is totally unacceptable".
Tygart claimed "it would provide a huge loophole for a cheater to step through," before pointing out that basketball star Kobe Bryant and swimming great Michael Phelps have both undergone random testing of this type. If it's good enough for Bryant and Phelps, why not Pacquiao?
Meanwhile, the sheriffs in Mayweather's camp have been tying themselves up in knots with contradictory statements.
Head of Golden Boy promotions Richard Schaefer, whose outfit is representing Mayweather, has been nagging in his insistence that Pacquiao agree to random testing, yet it has emerged that Schaefer turned down Zab Judah's request for additional testing before his scheduled fight with Shane Mosley in 2008.
In an interview with the Associated Press, Schaefer said Mosley would not agree to "other tests than the Nevada [Athletic] Commission requires. The fact is Shane is not a cheater and he does not need to be treated like one". So, pretty much what Pacquiao is saying now then.
Mosley, it should also be noted, has admitted to unwittingly using illegal substances in the past.
There's the intrigue, now for the comedy. If the fight does fall through, Pacquiao's promoter Bob Arum has suggested his man will fight New Yorker Paulie Malignaggi instead.
This is the same Paulie Malignaggi who was torn to shreds by Ricky Hatton in Las Vegas last year, and the same Paulie Malignaggi who, following Pacquiao's savage destruction of Miguel Cotto last month, hinted in a raft of interviews that Pacquiao's rise through the weight divisions has been fuelled by performance-enhancing drugs.
Meanwhile, Hatton's younger brother Matthew, who has never even fought for a British title, has confirmed his representatives are in talks to fight Mayweather in the UK if the Pacquiao bout falls through.
"At first I thought it was a wind-up when my name was mentioned for Mayweather," said Hatton, echoing the thoughts of just about everyone else. A rematch with his older brother would have been a tough enough sell.
Matthew Hatton is a very respectable domestic fighter, but as far as Mayweather is concerned, it's the equivalent passing on a Beverly Hills date with Angelina Jolie and plumping for pie and mash with some actress off Eastenders instead.
Enough of the intrigue and the comedy, now for the tragedy. While the big shots are trashing the place, digging their spurs in and waving their pieces around with scant regard for the consequences, it's the poor saps who love boxing who are suffering.
There have been signs in recent years that those who run the sport are getting their act together, have finally realised that only by regularly matching the best against the best will boxing regain a foothold in the public consciousness.
To his credit, Pacquiao, who has ducked no-one, has been at the forefront of this revival, so too Mayweather, although to a lesser extent.
But if they are unable to put aside their differences and make this fight happen, there's a danger they'll be remembered by many for the wrong reason - not as the men who saved boxing, but as the men who turned their backs when boxing needed them most.
As I write, news reaches me that Pacquiao has filed a lawsuit alleging that Mayweather and others have falsely accused him of using performance-enhancing drugs. From super-fight to super farce, whatever happens between Mayweather and Pacquiao in court, millions will find boxing guilty.
Source: bbc.co.uk
The FJ Fury 01.01.10: Mayweather-Pacquiao Impasse Surfaces a Lot of Hypocrisies, Contradictions, and Ironies
It's been a while, folks.
First of all, I want to wish you all a happy New Year.
For Christmas day, I know we boxing fans all wished for one thing for the sport: for the Pacquiao vs. Mayweather fight to happen.
Now, after witnessing a lot of tomfoolery go on and on about actually making that fight happen, we find ourselves wishing it again for the New Year.
If you look around at boxing sites from the most obscure internet source to the mainstream newspapers, the section of boxing and sports headlines the potential fight of the century between Mayweather and Pacquiao. There are a lot of nonsense going on, and, as one could imagine, even a lot more of nonsense being written. So, for all your updates and the coverage of the Mayweather-Pacquiao saga, make it a habit to check 411mania.com/boxing.
"The FJ Fury" returns and there's only one thing to talk about.
The negotiations for the pound-for-pound showdown of Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather, Jr. is at an impasse.
Now how many times have you read that this week? Strangely though, if the fight is at an impasse and is not moving, there should be nothing much to report about, right?
Well, not really. At least one news writer has filed this case inside the "Man Bites Dog" docket. That tells you a lot about how big this fight is. It could seriously be the biggest fight of all-time that any or all the issues pertaining to it can grab a news heading. First, the purse split; thought to be the detail that would be most difficult to settle, it was fixed most diplomatically. Then, the fight venue; everyone knew the fight was eventually landing in Las Vegas, but Jerry Jones put up a good fight-- damn would Mayweather-Pacquiao be great at the $1.2 billion, 100,000-capacity Cowboys Stadium! Everything IS bigger in Texas. That was headline-worthy as well.
The current stalemate the negotiation is standing at wrings the most balderdash but is also the most compelling so far. Truly a stalemate, as people are now looking at the discussions as a chess match between the two business sides. The fight is reportedly hanging in the balance, and all those problems root from one thing-- the drug tests.
As we all know, the camp of Mayweather Jr. asked for a special drug testing protocol for the fight. This is based on the accusations originally made by his father, Floyd Sr., about Pacquiao being on performance-enhancement drugs.
I guess special fights, with special fighters, should be given special treatments. That's why as baseless as one would argue Mayweather's allegations to be, you would give this one a pass. But as the issue sets sail, I observe a lot of hypocrisies, contradictions, and ironies from everyone involved surfacing.
The primary reason Mayweather Sr. may have sniffed something fishy about the freakish Filipino fighter is his ascension and domination to higher weight classes. Pacquiao went up from 106 all the way to a maximum of 144 lbs. in his last fight, and he continues to knock people down and out.
If this is unnatural to Floyd Sr., then how about his son? Junior fought as low as the super featherweight limit to the junior middleweight limit (130-154 pounds). Mayweather Jr. himself has stated that he was around the same weight that Pacquiao was as a teenager, only he was an amateur (he said this to demean Pacquiao's achievement in the professional ranks of winning a title in as low as the flyweight division and moving up in weight like he did). Clearly, Floyd Jr. understands the natural process of gaining weight (and subsequently, the special process of sustaining boxing success in that manner), so what is he yapping about?
A number of others have bought the ticket to the bandwagon, including the owner of Golden Boy Promotions (the company promoting Mayweather for this fight), the Golden Boy himself, Oscar De la Hoya. (By the way, Mayweather Jr. has always said that he is his own boss unlike Pacquiao, who has Bob Arum. So why is GBP promoting him in this fight? Hy-po-cri-ti-cal.)
Making the highly-respected Ring magazine website (which he also now owns) his soapbox blog, De la Hoya wrote these lines recently:
"I'm saying to myself, 'Wow. Those Mosley punches, those Vargas punches and those Pacquiao punches all felt the same.'"
As some of us would remember, De la Hoya blatantly said that Pacquiao doesn't hit hard and he didn't have enough power to knock him out. Bad Left Hook points out that De la Hoya's latest statement was either a contradiction or a lie. I'm picking De la Hoya's poison and picking the former.
The same source offered a 2008 quote from De la Hoya's gopher, and one of the most vocal representatives of Mayweather, Richard Schaefer. Schaefer was defending their stable's fighter, Shane Mosley, against submitting to other drug tests beyond what the Nevada State Athletic Commission requires. Yeah, and now the opponent of the fighter they represent should be enforced to? If Earl Hickey knows this, he would have said that this is hypochronical. Or hypoconjugal. Hypothetical?
Promoters are sometimes understood to be that way. They go out of their way to support their fighter and to criticize other fighters, even if they have to lie. Top Rank head honcho Bob Arum has never been at a loss for that (and hyperbole). Mayweather asked for an Olympic-style drug testing for his fight against Pacquiao, a standard that can be conducted by the United States Anti-Doping Agency (USADA). Such a test includes random blood testing at any time before the fight. According to Arum, Pacquiao refuses to have blood taken from him 30-days prior to the fight, and will only accept up to three "random" blood withdrawals: one at the kickoff press conference (originally scheduled for mid-January), 30 days before the fight, and right after the fight.
But, as one of my colleagues here at 411 noticed, Pacquiao was taped to have taken a blood test as close as 14 days to fight night (against Ricky Hatton in the HBO 24/7 show). Arum also indicated that Pacquiao doesn't have a liking to needles making contact with his body, but Pacquiao has tattoos all over his body.
Was Arum just putting words into Pacquiao's mouth? If he lied, no surprise there. Arum is a promoter now and a lawyer before that-- it just ups the chances of committing a lie! Furthermore, if Pacquiao really does think that blood withdrawal close to the fight can physically or mentally weaken him, or that he's just superstitious about it, then that HBO 24/7 clip puts punch holes in his argument. Thus, even Pacquiao doesn't escape this hypocrisy hysteria.
Another promoter, Leonard Ellerbe, the CEO of Mayweather's promotional outfit, said that his client has taken concessions to Pacquiao in the fight deal (the 50-50 purse split and the 147 lb. limit). If that doesn't fall under hypocrisy, contradiction, or irony... it's a lie. Oh, these promoters. The 50-50 purse split is arguable both ways, but at the end of the day, it is just. And the 147 lb. limit? Can anyone please tell me how that favors Pacquiao more than Mayweather? If I remember correctly, some reports indicated that Mayweather made absurd demands for the fight to take place at 154. Whether those are rumors of not, it's still absurd. So is Ellerbe's lie.
So Mayweather Jr. has conceivably trapped Pacquiao in the warfare outside the ring. Mayweather necessitated a stricter drug testing in the contract, Pacquiao budges at it, and now, some people are doubting Pacquiao. But it continues to befuddle many smart boxing fans how the onus is on Pacquiao to prove his innocence. It's a baseless accusation in the first place, something that should simply be ignored. Instead, it has worked its way as a legit concern. Shrewd Mayweathers.
So, what does Pacquiao do? He sues the Mayweathers.
The craziness in the Mayweather-Pacquiao negotiations has intensified another notch.
Those craziness floated up some normal human errors like hypocrisies, contradictions, ironies, and lies for the people involved. Perhaps they all should use mirrors and memory boosters to avoid it.
I'm susceptible to it as much as we all are. Like William Detloff, I think that if Mayweather really thinks that Pacquiao is on something, then by all means he is on his right by pushing it, if only to find the truth and protect himself. But I can't blame Pacquiao either by telling Mayweather Jr. to screw over and refusing to be pushed. He's on his right too. I'm pointing my finger at it yet I don't espouse the most constructive and fair solution. Maybe I'm hypocritical, contradictory, ironic, or a liar. I don't know.
But I do know this: amidst all this craziness, the craziest thing is for both Pacquiao and Mayweather to walk away from the kind of money they will make in this fight.
Crashing Right Hooks:
The random thoughts return as well, readers...
- If this fight falls through, there wouldn't be a replacement. And what I mean is there's no substitute to this event. You can't call a new opponent a "replacement." It just won't deserve it. This bout is as big as it ever, ever gets.
- But if it does, and hopefully and begrudgingly not, Pacquiao could be fighting Paulie Malignaggi. I know you would easily dismiss that as an easy Pacquiao win, but I have my reservations (not saying Pacquiao loses, though). If the news about Mayweather-Pacquiao still come along this slowly, I would write about it.
- This portion is called "Crashing Right Hooks", but I will talk about a certain left straight. It's called "The Pacquiao" over at the "other" sport (if you may label it) and it's getting pretty popular there. BJ Penn and Frank Mir said they used it to win their recent fights.
- It really sucks that Pacquiao is running for politics right now. The fight with Mayweather could be delayed and the event will be set up even bigger. If it gets pushed to late 2010 and they both take tune-up fights, I'll be fine with it as well. Pacquiao can fight Yuri Foreman at 154 for a title, or Malignaggi. As for Mayweather, err...
- If Malignaggi is not fighting Pacquiao, some have suggested that he fight in the undercard of Pacquiao-Mayweather to face Timothy Bradley. It's a main event on its own but for this once-in-a-generation event, a great undercard is a must.
- This just in: A video from TMZ was posted right here at 411 Boxing showing Mayweather toying and trash talking with a sparring partner (I won't give you the link but you can check it out, as it may be transferred to the Media section from News when our ed. comes back). Here's what I had to say in the comments: "What unimpressive? Did you see how Floyd quickly docked that punch early in the video? He was toying with this guy. What's unimpressive is him trash talking with the guy working with him. Good boxing, bad talking."
- Told you, it's all about Pacquiao vs. Mayweather.
- I will write about my decade's boxing awards soon. Just stay tuned.
- 411Maniacs, boxing fans, and everyone in between, let's talk about sports, stuffs, and everything in between! Follow my on Facebook and Twitter. Hit me there, and I'll hit you back. Thanks a lot!
Source: 411mania.com
First of all, I want to wish you all a happy New Year.
For Christmas day, I know we boxing fans all wished for one thing for the sport: for the Pacquiao vs. Mayweather fight to happen.
Now, after witnessing a lot of tomfoolery go on and on about actually making that fight happen, we find ourselves wishing it again for the New Year.
If you look around at boxing sites from the most obscure internet source to the mainstream newspapers, the section of boxing and sports headlines the potential fight of the century between Mayweather and Pacquiao. There are a lot of nonsense going on, and, as one could imagine, even a lot more of nonsense being written. So, for all your updates and the coverage of the Mayweather-Pacquiao saga, make it a habit to check 411mania.com/boxing.
"The FJ Fury" returns and there's only one thing to talk about.
The negotiations for the pound-for-pound showdown of Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather, Jr. is at an impasse.
Now how many times have you read that this week? Strangely though, if the fight is at an impasse and is not moving, there should be nothing much to report about, right?
Well, not really. At least one news writer has filed this case inside the "Man Bites Dog" docket. That tells you a lot about how big this fight is. It could seriously be the biggest fight of all-time that any or all the issues pertaining to it can grab a news heading. First, the purse split; thought to be the detail that would be most difficult to settle, it was fixed most diplomatically. Then, the fight venue; everyone knew the fight was eventually landing in Las Vegas, but Jerry Jones put up a good fight-- damn would Mayweather-Pacquiao be great at the $1.2 billion, 100,000-capacity Cowboys Stadium! Everything IS bigger in Texas. That was headline-worthy as well.
The current stalemate the negotiation is standing at wrings the most balderdash but is also the most compelling so far. Truly a stalemate, as people are now looking at the discussions as a chess match between the two business sides. The fight is reportedly hanging in the balance, and all those problems root from one thing-- the drug tests.
As we all know, the camp of Mayweather Jr. asked for a special drug testing protocol for the fight. This is based on the accusations originally made by his father, Floyd Sr., about Pacquiao being on performance-enhancement drugs.
I guess special fights, with special fighters, should be given special treatments. That's why as baseless as one would argue Mayweather's allegations to be, you would give this one a pass. But as the issue sets sail, I observe a lot of hypocrisies, contradictions, and ironies from everyone involved surfacing.
The primary reason Mayweather Sr. may have sniffed something fishy about the freakish Filipino fighter is his ascension and domination to higher weight classes. Pacquiao went up from 106 all the way to a maximum of 144 lbs. in his last fight, and he continues to knock people down and out.
If this is unnatural to Floyd Sr., then how about his son? Junior fought as low as the super featherweight limit to the junior middleweight limit (130-154 pounds). Mayweather Jr. himself has stated that he was around the same weight that Pacquiao was as a teenager, only he was an amateur (he said this to demean Pacquiao's achievement in the professional ranks of winning a title in as low as the flyweight division and moving up in weight like he did). Clearly, Floyd Jr. understands the natural process of gaining weight (and subsequently, the special process of sustaining boxing success in that manner), so what is he yapping about?
A number of others have bought the ticket to the bandwagon, including the owner of Golden Boy Promotions (the company promoting Mayweather for this fight), the Golden Boy himself, Oscar De la Hoya. (By the way, Mayweather Jr. has always said that he is his own boss unlike Pacquiao, who has Bob Arum. So why is GBP promoting him in this fight? Hy-po-cri-ti-cal.)
Making the highly-respected Ring magazine website (which he also now owns) his soapbox blog, De la Hoya wrote these lines recently:
"I'm saying to myself, 'Wow. Those Mosley punches, those Vargas punches and those Pacquiao punches all felt the same.'"
As some of us would remember, De la Hoya blatantly said that Pacquiao doesn't hit hard and he didn't have enough power to knock him out. Bad Left Hook points out that De la Hoya's latest statement was either a contradiction or a lie. I'm picking De la Hoya's poison and picking the former.
The same source offered a 2008 quote from De la Hoya's gopher, and one of the most vocal representatives of Mayweather, Richard Schaefer. Schaefer was defending their stable's fighter, Shane Mosley, against submitting to other drug tests beyond what the Nevada State Athletic Commission requires. Yeah, and now the opponent of the fighter they represent should be enforced to? If Earl Hickey knows this, he would have said that this is hypochronical. Or hypoconjugal. Hypothetical?
Promoters are sometimes understood to be that way. They go out of their way to support their fighter and to criticize other fighters, even if they have to lie. Top Rank head honcho Bob Arum has never been at a loss for that (and hyperbole). Mayweather asked for an Olympic-style drug testing for his fight against Pacquiao, a standard that can be conducted by the United States Anti-Doping Agency (USADA). Such a test includes random blood testing at any time before the fight. According to Arum, Pacquiao refuses to have blood taken from him 30-days prior to the fight, and will only accept up to three "random" blood withdrawals: one at the kickoff press conference (originally scheduled for mid-January), 30 days before the fight, and right after the fight.
But, as one of my colleagues here at 411 noticed, Pacquiao was taped to have taken a blood test as close as 14 days to fight night (against Ricky Hatton in the HBO 24/7 show). Arum also indicated that Pacquiao doesn't have a liking to needles making contact with his body, but Pacquiao has tattoos all over his body.
Was Arum just putting words into Pacquiao's mouth? If he lied, no surprise there. Arum is a promoter now and a lawyer before that-- it just ups the chances of committing a lie! Furthermore, if Pacquiao really does think that blood withdrawal close to the fight can physically or mentally weaken him, or that he's just superstitious about it, then that HBO 24/7 clip puts punch holes in his argument. Thus, even Pacquiao doesn't escape this hypocrisy hysteria.
Another promoter, Leonard Ellerbe, the CEO of Mayweather's promotional outfit, said that his client has taken concessions to Pacquiao in the fight deal (the 50-50 purse split and the 147 lb. limit). If that doesn't fall under hypocrisy, contradiction, or irony... it's a lie. Oh, these promoters. The 50-50 purse split is arguable both ways, but at the end of the day, it is just. And the 147 lb. limit? Can anyone please tell me how that favors Pacquiao more than Mayweather? If I remember correctly, some reports indicated that Mayweather made absurd demands for the fight to take place at 154. Whether those are rumors of not, it's still absurd. So is Ellerbe's lie.
So Mayweather Jr. has conceivably trapped Pacquiao in the warfare outside the ring. Mayweather necessitated a stricter drug testing in the contract, Pacquiao budges at it, and now, some people are doubting Pacquiao. But it continues to befuddle many smart boxing fans how the onus is on Pacquiao to prove his innocence. It's a baseless accusation in the first place, something that should simply be ignored. Instead, it has worked its way as a legit concern. Shrewd Mayweathers.
So, what does Pacquiao do? He sues the Mayweathers.
The craziness in the Mayweather-Pacquiao negotiations has intensified another notch.
Those craziness floated up some normal human errors like hypocrisies, contradictions, ironies, and lies for the people involved. Perhaps they all should use mirrors and memory boosters to avoid it.
I'm susceptible to it as much as we all are. Like William Detloff, I think that if Mayweather really thinks that Pacquiao is on something, then by all means he is on his right by pushing it, if only to find the truth and protect himself. But I can't blame Pacquiao either by telling Mayweather Jr. to screw over and refusing to be pushed. He's on his right too. I'm pointing my finger at it yet I don't espouse the most constructive and fair solution. Maybe I'm hypocritical, contradictory, ironic, or a liar. I don't know.
But I do know this: amidst all this craziness, the craziest thing is for both Pacquiao and Mayweather to walk away from the kind of money they will make in this fight.
Crashing Right Hooks:
The random thoughts return as well, readers...
- If this fight falls through, there wouldn't be a replacement. And what I mean is there's no substitute to this event. You can't call a new opponent a "replacement." It just won't deserve it. This bout is as big as it ever, ever gets.
- But if it does, and hopefully and begrudgingly not, Pacquiao could be fighting Paulie Malignaggi. I know you would easily dismiss that as an easy Pacquiao win, but I have my reservations (not saying Pacquiao loses, though). If the news about Mayweather-Pacquiao still come along this slowly, I would write about it.
- This portion is called "Crashing Right Hooks", but I will talk about a certain left straight. It's called "The Pacquiao" over at the "other" sport (if you may label it) and it's getting pretty popular there. BJ Penn and Frank Mir said they used it to win their recent fights.
- It really sucks that Pacquiao is running for politics right now. The fight with Mayweather could be delayed and the event will be set up even bigger. If it gets pushed to late 2010 and they both take tune-up fights, I'll be fine with it as well. Pacquiao can fight Yuri Foreman at 154 for a title, or Malignaggi. As for Mayweather, err...
- If Malignaggi is not fighting Pacquiao, some have suggested that he fight in the undercard of Pacquiao-Mayweather to face Timothy Bradley. It's a main event on its own but for this once-in-a-generation event, a great undercard is a must.
- This just in: A video from TMZ was posted right here at 411 Boxing showing Mayweather toying and trash talking with a sparring partner (I won't give you the link but you can check it out, as it may be transferred to the Media section from News when our ed. comes back). Here's what I had to say in the comments: "What unimpressive? Did you see how Floyd quickly docked that punch early in the video? He was toying with this guy. What's unimpressive is him trash talking with the guy working with him. Good boxing, bad talking."
- Told you, it's all about Pacquiao vs. Mayweather.
- I will write about my decade's boxing awards soon. Just stay tuned.
- 411Maniacs, boxing fans, and everyone in between, let's talk about sports, stuffs, and everything in between! Follow my on Facebook and Twitter. Hit me there, and I'll hit you back. Thanks a lot!
Source: 411mania.com
Manny Pacquiao set for new weight challenge as Floyd Mayweather showdown hopes fade

Manny Pacquiao was yesterday being lined up to challenge for a title in an eighth different weight division with his fight against Floyd Mayweather junior looking doomed.
Talks have failed to resolve a row over Pacquiao rejecting Mayweather's demand for random blood tests for performance enhancing drugs.
Instead of taking on the American in Las Vegas on March 13, Pacquiao may face New York-based Yuri Foreman for the Israeli's WBA lightmiddleweight crown a week later.
Although negotiations with Mayweather's camp are still going on, Filipino Pacquiao's promoter, Bob Arum, was not optimistic.
"We contacted Manny and his position is firm, irrevocable," he said. "He instructed us to pursue another fight, period. I don't see the fight happening now."
Source: mirror.co.uk
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)